A man and his family AI media incident — Sep 2024
The Himachal Pradesh High Court quashed an FIR involving AI-generated defamatory content, ruling that such material does not meet the legal threshold for.
- Incident date
- Sep 2, 2024
- Source report date
- Nov 21, 2026
- Target
- A man and his family
In September 2024, the Himachal Pradesh High Court quashed an FIR filed against two individuals accused of circulating AI-generated videos and photographs on Facebook that allegedly defamed a man and his family. The court ruled that the mere circulation of AI-generated content containing false information does not constitute forgery under the law.
What happened
The case originated from a complaint by a man who alleged that AI-generated media depicted him and his family in various false scenarios. These included claims that he was publicizing a family scheme for personal gain, collecting money and fleeing, and that his relatives had secured government positions or director roles through illicit means. Following the complaint, the Ghumarwin police in Bilaspur district registered an FIR on September 2, 2024, citing sections of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) related to criminal intimidation, defamation, and forgery to harm reputation.
During the investigation, police dropped the criminal intimidation charge but added a section regarding the circulation of false information intended to cause public fear or alarm. Authorities seized mobile phones, sent the digital media to a forensic laboratory, and contacted Facebook to identify the account holder. However, Justice Rakesh Kainthla observed that the FIR failed to allege that the content was falsely projected as being created by someone else, altered without authority, or obtained through deception. The court held that the police could not use cognizable offenses as a subterfuge to investigate a private defamation complaint, which is a non-cognizable offense requiring a complaint before a competent magistrate. Consequently, the court quashed the FIR and all associated proceedings, noting that the state failed to demonstrate how the content could induce public fear or alarm.